A Method of Attack

  Documenting the Story of the Battle of Agincourt

Another way to go about examining your proof is to create a chart similar to the one below. Fill in a column for each web site that you find information. The read across each row to make decisions about  what is true and what is false.  Don't forget to use just plain old logic!  What is the likelihood of 5000 wet, weary, battle warn soldiers jumping up and down like middle schoolers, yelling "We can still pluck  ewe!"  Did it occur to anyone that the troops didn't even speak the same language?!?
 

Click and Clack

Richard Harrold

 

 

 

French were 
overwhelmingly favored to win

Agree - they outnumbered Henry's army by about seven to one

 

 

 

French threatened to cut off the middle finger

Middle and index finger

 

 

 

English won in a major upset

Agree

 

 

 

English waved the middle finger at the French in defiance

Conscious that it was the v-shaped notch which was the difference between the two armies' relative fortunes that day, the archers filed past the captured French waving v-shaped fingers and elbows 

 

 

 

Longbow made of the native English yew tree

 Not Mentioned

 

 

 

Pulling bow was called plucking yew

Disagree - The "pluck yew" is pure invention - although ingenious.

 

 

 

English said, "See, we can still pluck yew! 

Think about it! The French speak French, not English!

 

 

 

Congratulations for reading through the entire page. As your reward I will give you a clue that will help you discover significant information.   I will tell you this TRUE fact.  The incident of English archers  waving their defiant gesture to the French was written about by Jean Froissart.  He was a medieval historian who wrote as series of books called Chronicles.  You won't find the passages describing the  story on Internet, but you will find information about Jean Froissart.  If you have been reading and learning about the Battle of Agincourt, by carefully reading about his life, one of those light bulbs should  flash over your head as you realize a major error in the story.

[ Back ]

[ OII Home Page ]

[Index] [Net Basics] [Web Basics] [Search] [Glossary]